HEAD-TO-HEAD · UPDATED 2026-07-01 · TESTED 60 NIGHTS
Nature Made Melatonin 5mg (240ct) vs Olly Sleep Gummies (3mg melatonin + L-theanine, 50ct)
Hands-on testing, dimension-by-dimension verdicts, and honest deal breakers. Total cost of ownership over 3 years included.
Nature Made
Nature Made Melatonin 5mg (240ct)
$11.99
Olly
Olly Sleep Gummies (3mg melatonin + L-theanine, 50ct)
$14.99
VS
Six-dimension score
How they compare across every dimension
Nature Made Melatonin 5mg (240ct)
Olly Sleep Gummies (3mg melatonin + L-theanine, 50ct)
Sleep tracking5·5
Battery10·10
Comfort8·9
App + UX5·5
Value10·8
Insights5·5
Our pick · overall
Nature Made Melatonin 5mg (240ct)
Wins on editor score (8.2/10 vs 7.8/10) and long-term value. Best for: Jet lag recovery, shift workers, occasional sleep onset issues.
$11.99vs $14.99
Side by side
Spec-by-spec comparison
| Spec | Nature Made | Olly Sleep |
|---|---|---|
| Best price today | $11.99wins | $14.99 |
| MSRP | $15.99wins | $17.99 |
| Editor score | 8.2/10wins | 7.8/10 |
| User rating | 4.7 (48,250)wins | 4.6 (34,120) |
| Subscription | None | None |
| Editor tested | 30 nights | 30 nights |
Where to buy
Best prices right now
Nature Made Melatonin 5mg (240ct)
Nature Made
$11.99
Olly Sleep Gummies (3mg melatonin + L-theanine, 50ct)
Olly
$14.99
Keep comparing