HEAD-TO-HEAD · UPDATED 2026-07-03

Bigelow Sweet Dreams Herbal Tea vs Celestial Seasonings Sleepytime Extra

Spec-based scoring, dimension-by-dimension verdicts, and honest deal breakers. Total cost of ownership over 3 years included.

Bigelow

Bigelow Sweet Dreams Herbal Tea

$9.18

(Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)

Celestial Seasonings

Celestial Seasonings Sleepytime Extra

$4.65

(Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)

4-dimension score

How they compare across every dimension

Bigelow Sweet Dreams Herbal Tea

Celestial Seasonings Sleepytime Extra

Taste8·8

Ingredient quality7·7.5

Purity6.5·7

Value8.5·8.5

Our pick · overall

Celestial Seasonings Sleepytime Extra

Wins on editor score (8.4/10 vs 7.6/10) and long-term value. Best for: Valerian in a familiar mint-chamomile flavour, cheapest of the valerian teas.

$4.65 (Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)vs $9.18 (Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)

Shop Celestial Seasonings at best price ↗Full Celestial Seasonings review →

Side by side

Spec-by-spec comparison

Spec	Bigelow Sweet	Celestial Seasonings
Best price today	$9.18 (Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)	$4.65 (Amazon price as of Oct 11, 20:51 UTC – Details)wins
MSRP	$7.84	$4.96wins
Editor score	7.6/10	8.4/10wins
Shopper rating	4.7 (39,000)wins	4.5 (22,400)
Subscription	None	None

Free, by email

Free · no card

Help for nights your mind won't switch off.

Two free printables now, then four short emails: one change to try tonight, how to choose, and what we'd skip.

Free. Five short emails over two weeks, then about one a month. Unsubscribe any time.

Where to buy

Best prices right now