HEAD-TO-HEAD · UPDATED 2026-10-23

Hatch Restore 3 vs Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)

Spec-based scoring, dimension-by-dimension verdicts, and honest deal breakers. Total cost of ownership over 3 years included.

Hatch Restore 3
Hatch
Hatch Restore 3
$135.99
(Amazon price as of – Details)
Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)
Loftie
Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)
Check price
VS
The 60-second verdict

Get Hatch Restore if

You want light to do the waking: a sunrise alarm, a wind-down light and sleep sounds set up as one routine, and you are fine with an app, Wi-Fi and an optional membership.

Buy at Amazon ↗

Get Loftie Clock if

You wake to sound rather than light, you want 100+ sounds included with nothing to subscribe to, and you want the clock to keep running with no phone and no Wi-Fi after setup.

Buy at Amazon ↗

Tied on

Both are built to get the phone off the nightstand, both need their app for setup, both play sleep sounds, and both brands offer a 30-night trial and a 1-year warranty.

5-dimension score

How they compare across every dimension

Sunrise qualityFeaturesEase of useBuild qualityValue
Hatch Restore 3
Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)
Sunrise quality8·5.5
Features9·8.5
Ease of use7.5·7.5
Build quality8.5·8
Value6.5·7

Buyer self-select

Best for you if…

If you…Pick
Best sunrise alarmHatch Restore
Best with nothing to subscribe toLoftie Clock
Best for building a bedtime routineHatch Restore
Best without Wi-FiLoftie Clock
Best gentle sound-only wakeLoftie Clock
Best as a bedside speakerLoftie Clock
Our pick · overall

Hatch Restore 3

For most people choosing between the two, the Hatch does more of the job: a real sunrise alarm plus routines and sleep sounds. The Loftie wins for anyone who wakes to sound, wants every sound included and never wants to see a membership offer.

$135.99 (Amazon price as of – Details)vs Check price

Deep dive

The head-to-head, dimension by dimension

Waking up: light or sound

Winner: Hatch Restore

The Hatch is a sunrise alarm. Hatch describes its light moving from red to orange to white before your chosen alarm sound, so the room brightens before anything plays. Its product page gives no brightness figure.

The Loftie Clock is not, and Loftie says so plainly: its nightlight can be set to come on with your alarm, but it is not a sunrise simulation, and Loftie sells the separate Loftie Lamp for light-based waking. The Loftie's waking is done by sound, through its two-phase alarm. If you sleep in a dark room and want light to start the job, the Hatch is the one of these two that does it.

Sleep sounds and audio

Winner: Loftie Clock

Loftie includes 100+ tracks with the clock: nature sounds, white and brown noise, sound baths, meditations and breathwork, all played on the clock itself, with no paywall. It also works as a Bluetooth speaker.

The Hatch's sleep sounds are free and pre-loaded, per Hatch's help centre, and Hatch+ adds a larger library of music, meditations, bedtime podcasts and stories. If you will not pay for a membership, the Loftie gives you more audio out of the box. If you will, the Hatch library is the bigger one to draw from.

Bedtime routine

Winner: Hatch Restore

Routines are the Hatch's core. In its app you chain a wind-down light, sleep sounds and the morning sunrise, then start the routine each night with the big button on top and step through it from the device.

The Loftie has the parts of a routine: bedtime reminders, a sleep timer, a red mode and a blackout mode for the display. It does not program them into one evening sequence the way the Hatch does. If the wind-down is what you want to fix, the Hatch does more of that work for you.

Wi-Fi, app and phone-free use

Winner: Loftie Clock

Both need their app for setup. After that the Loftie is the more independent device: Loftie says Wi-Fi is only for setup and updates, offers a No Wi-Fi Mode once the clock is updated, runs alarms on the clock itself, and lists a 5-7 hour backup battery.

Hatch lists a 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi connection as required and uses the app to customise routines, though once registered the Restore 3 runs nightly from its own buttons. If you want the bedroom device to keep working with the router off, the Loftie is built for it.

Subscription and 3-year cost

Winner: Loftie Clock

Loftie's position is simple: everything the clock does is included when you buy it, with nothing to subscribe to. The Hatch works without Hatch+, and Hatch lists its sleep sounds, light options, sunrise alarm, rest reminder and three sunset options as free. The membership adds music, meditations, podcasts and stories, and after the 30-day free trial it renews monthly or yearly unless you cancel.

With three years of the yearly Hatch+ plan, the Loftie's one-time price comes out lower over three years; without the membership, compare the two device prices.

Price

Tie

Hatch sells direct as well as on Amazon, so Amazon stock comes and goes. On device price alone, compare the two live prices on this page; the Loftie's price includes every sound with no membership to add later.

Side by side

Spec-by-spec comparison

SpecHatch RestoreLoftie Clock
Best price today$135.99 (Amazon price as of – Details)Check price
Editor score8.4/10wins8.2/10
SubscriptionOptional, $5.99/moNonewins
Free, by email
Free · no card

A darker, quieter bedroom, by the evidence.

Five short emails on light, noise and travel sleep: what the research supports, what to buy and what we would skip.

Free. Five short emails over two weeks, then about one a month. Unsubscribe any time.

Where to buy

Best prices right now

Hatch Restore 3

Hatch Restore 3

Hatch

$135.99$169.99
(Amazon price as of – Details)
Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)

Loftie Clock (2nd Gen)

Loftie

Check price

People also ask

Frequently asked questions

Hatch Restore 3 or Loftie Clock: which is better?

If you want light to wake you, the Hatch: it is a sunrise alarm with routines and sleep sounds. If you wake to sound and want everything included with no membership, the Loftie. Loftie itself says its clock is not a sunrise alarm.

Is the Loftie Clock a sunrise alarm?

No, and Loftie says so. Its nightlight can be set to turn on with your alarm, but it does not simulate a sunrise; Loftie sells the Loftie Lamp for light-based waking. The Hatch Restore 3 is a sunrise alarm.

Does either need a subscription?

The Loftie has none: Loftie says the alarm, 100+ sounds, nightlight and app are all included. The Hatch works without one, but Hatch+ adds music, meditations, bedtime podcasts and stories, and renews monthly or yearly after a 30-day free trial.

Which works without Wi-Fi or a phone?

Both need their app for setup. The Loftie then offers a No Wi-Fi Mode, runs its alarms on the clock and has a 5-7 hour backup battery, per Loftie. Hatch lists a 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi connection as required, and after registration you can use the Restore 3 each night from its buttons.

What is the Loftie's two-phase alarm?

A gentle first tone eases you out of sleep, then a second cue follows 3, 6 or 9 minutes later, depending on the setting. Loftie says the first phase fades out automatically after 30 seconds.

Which costs less over three years?

Without Hatch+, it comes down to the two device prices, so compare them on this page. With Hatch+ on the yearly plan, the Loftie's one-time price comes out lower over three years.